Login | Staff | Feedback | Customer Service | RSS | Advertise | Subscriber Services
customer service

HomeOpinion & EditorialColumnists

Brent Batten: Returning to normalcy at GOP convention

— The band was one indication things are getting back to normal at the Republican National Convention Tuesday night.

The full slate of speakers was another.

But the surest sign that the subdued mood that gripped the Xcel Energy Center Monday was passing was the return of the rhetoric.

On Monday Republicans managed to do without a live band, a scratchy recording of the National Anthem being the only song played. They got by with just brief remarks by First Lady Laura Bush and by Cindy McCain, wife of nominee John McCain, on the topic of relief for victims of Hurricane Gustav.

And they largely avoided partisan attacks against Democrats in general and that party’s presidential nominee Barack Obama in particular.

That changed Tuesday as U.S. Rep. John Boehner, chairman of the convention, laid into Democrats just moments after gaveling day two of the convention to order.

“When (Americans) look at the Democratic Congress, they see politicians more interested in taking care of themselves,” Boehner said.

He tried to portray Republicans as the party of reform, a mantle Obama has claimed for himself and his party.

“People sent a message in 2006,” Boehner said, referring to the election that saw Republicans lose their majority in both houses of Congress. “And reminded us they’re in charge. Nancy Pelosi, Harry Reid and Barack Obama ignored it.”

He cited the inability of Democrats to reform the earmark process and to pass an energy bill as two examples of the party’s failure to embrace reform.

“Washington is broken and the Democratic Congress is its most visible symbol,” Boehner said.

The undercard of speakers leading up to featured addresses by former Sen. Fred Thompson, Sen. Joe Leiberman and President George W. Bush (via video), worked in subtle digs at Democrats as they pointed out differences between the two parties.

U.S. Senator Norm Coleman, a former mayor of St. Paul currently running for re-election against TV and radio personality Al Franken, repeated the theme of reform at the hands of Republicans. “Let’s offer America a genuine hope of change that Republicans can actually deliver,” Coleman said.

Then he got in a shot at the opposition. Delivering a brief lesson on the history of St. Paul, Coleman recalled a time when the mayor was quoted as saying, “I’m not indecisive, am I?”

“That could have been an Obama campaign slogan.”

U.S. Rep. Michele Bachmann of Minnesota spoke about the importance of public service, whether through military duty, as exemplified by John McCain, or serving as a foster parent, as she has done. Then came the obligatory knock on Obama and his party. “Some presidential nominees know more about public service than others,” she said.

“Government is not a philanthropic organization. Government is not the family. Government is not the church. There are people who feel a little differently and we heard from them last week,” Bachmann said, adding, “They think you should be footing the bill.”

With the headliner speakers yet to appear, Tuesday’s rhetoric from the dais didn’t qualify as a full-bore offensive against Democrats, as Democrats waged against Republicans in Denver, but it was a move in that direction.

Another sign the convention is getting back to normal — Florida’s delegates were to head to a lavish Disney-sponsored party themed after the movie “National Treasure” right after Tuesday’s meeting closed.

* * *

The Republican Party platform adopted Monday is about half the size of the 40,000-word version it replaced.

But something’s been added that will be of interest to Floridians.

The party platform for the first time endorses the concept of a national catastrophic insurance program.

It doesn’t detail the specifics of what such a plan would look like but as generally envisioned, a fund would be available to augment existing state and private insurance policies, kicking in if damages reach a certain level. The theory is, rates could be held down if companies know their potential losses are limited. Coverage would be for disasters ranging from hurricanes to earthquakes.

Paul Senft of Haines City, a member of the Republican National Committee who helped draft the platform, said it’s the first time a national party has acknowledged the need for a national catastrophic insurance plan, or Cat fund.

The national Cat fund idea is not popular in the interior states, where hurricanes and earthquakes aren’t a factor. But those areas are prone to tornadoes and floods, Senft noted. The inclusion of the language in the platform indicates Republicans are nearing consensus on the topic, he said.

Democrats have traditionally been more supportive of a national Cat fund but didn’t include language supporting one in their platform adopted last week, according to Senft. “I hope the other party will amend their platform to include it. It doesn’t matter who gets the credit, it’s the people who need it,” Senft said.

Senft said the coincidental arrival of Hurricane Gustav just as Republicans were gathering to approve their 2008 platform was not a factor in including support for a Cat fund. The language was inserted a week ago, before the threat of Gustav was clear, he said.

Republican presidential candidate John McCain has not been in favor of a national Cat fund. But at least, Senft noted, he didn’t oppose it being in the platform.

* * *

After Monday’s prayerful and apolitical beginning, the convention was slowly transitioning back toward its envisioned agenda.

Florida delegates were asked to remember the Gulf Coast and reminded of prayer services today organized by the Louisiana and Texas delegations.

But at their daily breakfast meeting, they indulged in a few partisan jabs at the opposition.

Senft joked that daredevil Robbie Knievel was planning a stunt in the Twin Cities. “He’s going to try to jump over 5,000 (Barack) Obama supporters with a bulldozer.”

Most of the morning session was devoted to pollster Frank Luntz, who does work for Fox News. Luntz, author of the book, “Words that Work,” talked about ways to frame the political discussion to benefit Republicans.

Instead of talking about “tort reform,” Republicans should discuss “lawsuit abuse reform,” he said. “Drilling for oil,” should be “offshore energy exploration,” and the “estate tax” should be renamed the “death tax,” Luntz said.

Based on his work with focus groups, Luntz said Republicans should stress five areas where McCain enjoys an advantage over Democratic presidential candidate Obama.

First is accountability, the ability to mean what one says and say what one means, Luntz said. “There is no one in American politics with more straight talk than John McCain,” he said.

Other McCain strengths include his perceived wisdom, experience, his policies on energy independence and finally, “who John McCain is and what he’s experienced.”

McCain’s military service and captivity translate into an ability to stand up against lobbyists, bureaucrats and other impediments to good government, Luntz argued. “For 5 1/2 years they (Vietnamese) tried to break John McCain and they couldn’t. And he’s stronger today than he was then,” Luntz said.

Luntz shared a few predictions on the November election. The 18 to 24 age group is solidly behind Obama. “That’s not where the swing vote lies,” he said. Middle income Americans in the 40 to 59 age group are those most likely to come over to McCain, Luntz predicted.

McCain must win Florida to have any chance in the election, according to Luntz. He singled out Ohio and Michigan as two other states important to both candidates. A McCain win in Michigan would be a huge bonus, but he believes it is possible. “Michigan is fed up with Democrats,” Luntz asserted.

He said the presence of Sarah Palin on the ticket with McCain has energized Republicans but cautioned she still has tests ahead. “She has got to deliver an awesome speech Wednesday night,” he said.

It is important she be characterized as a reformer who took on a corrupt governor in Alaska, one from her own party, and won. “America wants a winner. In effect, she’s had it all, she’s done it all and she’s been successful.”

Luntz conceded that polling this far ahead of an election is unreliable but said he’s seeing reasons for optimism among Republicans. “Two months ago I would have told you there was no way John McCain was going to win. Now he’s got a reasonable chance,” Luntz said.

* * *

Collier County Republican Party Chairwoman Carla Dean offered the opening invocation at Tuesday’s delegation breakfast. Lt. Gov. Jeff Kottkamp of Cape Coral was the honoree at an afternoon reception.

Speaking to delegates at the reception, Kottkamp turned his attention away from Florida and toward international affairs. Saying terrorists want to kill Americans and destroy our way of life, Kottkamp told delegates, “This is a high stakes battle we’re waging in the Middle East and John McCain understands that. We’re going to hear that starting tonight. We must win this election.”

* * *

Protesters by the thousands have been gathering in St. Paul to confront convention delegates. A group of them blocked a route Florida’s delegation buses were trying to take on their way from the Xcel Center to their hotel Monday, forcing the buses to take an alternate route.

Police estimate about 10,000 protesters are in town. Most of the demonstrations and marches have been peaceful, but police reported about 290 arrests Monday, roughly half for felonies. That is almost double the roughly 150 arrests recorded by Denver police during the entire Democratic National Convention last week.

Comments

This site does not necessarily agree with comments posted below. Comments are the sole responsibility of the person posting them. Break our rules, and we will ban you. No exceptions, no second chances. Read our privacy policy & user agreement.


While watching the RNC Convention I am noticing that everyone on the television is an old white guy. I someday will be an old white guy. However, these old white guys on the television are the ones who brought us to this point. They are the ones who have been running things and running them poorly.

It makes me notice that this election is more about getting new ideas from people who have knowledge of modern practices and ideas rather than those who tote experience. John McCain doesn't use email, doesn't use a teleprompter (he uses paper notes). I have to ask myself would I hire my 78 year old Uncle to run my company or a 47 year old Harvard Grad.

I do know that I go to doctors who have a clue on modern knowledge of medical practice and that the old country doctor wouldn't be my choice to run an MRI exam on me.

#1 Posted by artdude on September 2, 2008 at 10:37 p.m. (Suggest removal)

Oh look, it is T-W: "Kollier" County's most racist, angry, hated and moronic liberal complaining some more!

#2 Posted by jim09091 on September 3, 2008 at 12:37 a.m. (Suggest removal)

"Republican presidential candidate John McCain has not been in favor of a national Cat fund. But at least, Senft noted, he didn’t oppose it being in the platform."

John McCain didn't oppose ANYTHING in the platform, apparently. And that includes the provision that would ban abortions regardless of circumstance, a stance far from where Mr. Straight Talk once claimed to be.

I wonder, too, when his team of Rove-led lobbyists informed him that the "soul mate" he'd only met twice was going to be his veep choice.

McCain will do anything to get elected. We know Karl Rove will do anything to win. The debates should be a blast.

And shame on you, Tookie, for wearing your pork chop suit to the pit bull pen.

#3 Posted by elnuestros on September 3, 2008 at 4:44 a.m. (Suggest removal)

Other than the Fred Thompson's speech, it was a rather uneventful evening and quite boring. Thompson was the best speaker of the night, even if misguided. Lieberman was probably the most boring speaker... YAWN. He also lied when he claimed he was a Democrat. Democrats voted him OUT in 2006. He's now an Indepndent, and they can have him.

Tonight we'll get to her Sarah Palin. I expect her the give the best speech of the entire convention. Hearing her speak in the past, I think we know she's good at it.... at least when reading from a teleprompt anyway. How she does in the debates, may be another story.

Tonight, I expect Sarah Palin to slam it out of the park.

#4 Posted by Ironside on September 3, 2008 at 7:29 a.m. (Suggest removal)

Lieberman is Judas in the flesh. A traitor and turncoat who will do WHATEVER is necessary to get elected and/or re-elected. He abandoned his party in the likes of Benedict Arnold because HIS state (CT) voted him out. We see what happened to Benedict Arnold and the same will happen to Lieberman when OBAMA is elected.

#5 Posted by Lemme on September 3, 2008 at 8:37 a.m. (Suggest removal)

artdude: I watched last night, but saw a lot of other people, not just "old white guys" perhaps your TV needs adjusting!

I have always admired those who serve the public who followed the principles highlighted in a wonderful book by one of our former Presidents. Profiles in Courage is a great book Lemme, I would recommend it to you before you pass judgment on principled individuals such as Senator Lieberman. The Democratic party dissed their former VEEP candidate and yet he won as an Independent. Like he said in his speech last night, many of us who vote are not "Democrats OR Republicans" but Americans.
I fall in the last category! I admire Lieberman, I voted for Shirley Chisholm for President when she ran (had to do a write in in my state then), I liked Ronald Reagan, loved John Kennedy, and appreciated Bill Clinton for some of his leadership.

I am not to be pigeonholed by some pollster or party. If I could vote for Joe Lieberman, I would. I admire him.

Anyone who could endure the torture of the Viet Cong will stand up for his country. McCain, does not need to be President. He wants to serve for the same reasons he survived his imprisonment: he truly loves his country. I am impressed by him, too. Do I think there will be a role in the future for Obama? Yes, but he is more style than substance right now and backed by a machine of which I am suspicious (Chicago Democratic Machine).

I will vote this November not based on Party Politics or slogans. I will vote not based on the "band wagon" effect or the medias' influence. I will vote in November based on my love of country and look to those who have the kind of courage profiled so well in President John Kennedy's book. I will vote as an American.

No matter who you vote for, vote not for the party...vote as an American.

#6 Posted by BlueTonguedVole on September 3, 2008 at 9:43 a.m. (Suggest removal)

CENSORSHIP.....

Sarah tried to ban books from local library when she was mayor!

The People for the American Way want an explanation!

The Article:
http://www.politicalplace.com/phpBB3/...

#7 Posted by Ironside on September 3, 2008 at 9:44 a.m. (Suggest removal)

BTV, you can vote for Lieberman. You can vote for anybody you want. This is America.

#8 Posted by Ironside on September 3, 2008 at 9:46 a.m. (Suggest removal)

And...to you who want to slam each other on this blog with nasty personal remark; please, find a positive outlet. Debate with respect shows your intelligence. Debate with personal slams reflects poorly on you.

CLT, you are bright and have some excellent points which can be obscured by some unfortunate word choices. Too many others resort to a level of discourse which I doubt will convince others and only degrades the entire discussion.

Batten is a commentator and not a reporter. His glasses don't have a rose colored tint but perhaps are a bit jaundiced. We all have our perspectives which blind us to what is really going on. But please let us all be respectful. CTL, I didn't single you out because I want to slam you, I did because we have had healthy exchanges before and I do respect your commentary.

The bottom line for me, is that I know who I am voting for. I am not going to try to convince you all to see it my way, but I hope you will step back and look at the big picture. Comment all you want, but slamming others who blog here or personally going after any of those running seems out of bounds. How about the issues? Not the past, but what we can plan for in the future. Think forward.

Take care...ALL of you. Will see you at the polls in November.

#9 Posted by BlueTonguedVole on September 3, 2008 at 9:58 a.m. (Suggest removal)

Ironside: Thank you. I did exercise this kind of choice in the past when I voted for Shirley Chisholm as a write in. Met her, liked her perspective and I voted for her. She was ahead of her time.

I am going to support Senator Lieberman in another way.

#10 Posted by BlueTonguedVole on September 3, 2008 at 10:01 a.m. (Suggest removal)

So what about party platforms? Once elected, the president can lead the way he desires. We all know that both candidates are professional liars and they basically have to go along to get along. Either way, it's good to know that there's a very good possibility that most of the Democrat and Republican blowhards on these pages will be very disappointed. Only then we can know that the American people are finally getting their due.

#11 Posted by wes on September 3, 2008 at 10:10 a.m. (Suggest removal)

sunshinelover, what handout is it that CTL is looking for? I think I missed something in this discussion. Please help me out.

Thank you.

#12 Posted by Ironside on September 3, 2008 at 10:14 a.m. (Suggest removal)

CTL: I am sorry I missed the exchange you noted. I must have read too fast. My sincere apology.
The reason I mentioned you is because you are not as likely to react irrationally. As I said, I think you are a bright thinking person. Others are too, but get caught in a degraded commentary. It is too bad as there is a lot we can discuss.

While I also agree that there is a benefit to more disclosure, there is some good rationale for anonymity. Key for me is to do what you do. Tell the truth. Being civil also helps keep it interesting.

By being civil/polite and considerate that we can't tell someone we think they are dead wrong, or post some fun things.

As far as my age: depends on what you consider "older"! LOL. I am quite young compared to many and very old to my youngest grandchild. My daughter, son and wife keep me thinking very "young", yet I have benefit of experience. I am a "boomer" and part of the group that tried hard to change the world. Some of us are still trying.

I wish you best regards CTL and appreciate reading your perspective.

#13 Posted by BlueTonguedVole on September 3, 2008 at 12:13 p.m. (Suggest removal)

Darnit. Please add 'doesn't mean' to the sentence starting with "By being civil" etc. So it reads By being civil/polite and considerate "doesn't mean" that we can't tell someone that we think they are dead wrong,...etc."

NOW, I feel old, LOL. My mind and hands weren't keeping the same time.

#14 Posted by BlueTonguedVole on September 3, 2008 at 12:17 p.m. (Suggest removal)

McCain's Brain: Checking Out His VP

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9qUVQD...

#15 Posted by bicoastal on September 3, 2008 at 1:40 p.m. (Suggest removal)

CTL re: 31 Oh...LOL, well as I said my youngest grandchild thinks I am "old"!

Yep, would be interesting to get the perspective of osceolaoldtimer. Perhaps he will be back. Some of the thoughts sound authentic.

And, for the record, no matter who wins...we really do need to come together as a country as we have some really powerful enemies just chomping at the bit if we remain at each other's throat! There will be common ground if we look for it.

Take care.

#16 Posted by BlueTonguedVole on September 3, 2008 at 4:01 p.m. (Suggest removal)

#10 Biden also has a kid in the military and he is headed to Iraq. Obama's kids are a bit too young, I will hold comment on that.

Capt. Beau Biden, a Judge Advocate General in the Delaware National Guard and the state's attorney general, is part of the 261st Signal Brigade that has been told to prepare for duty in Iraq in 2008. They have not been given a date of deployment yet.

#17 Posted by artdude on September 3, 2008 at 4:11 p.m. (Suggest removal)



Post your comment
(Requires free registration.)

Username:

Password:
(Forgotten your password?)

Your Turn:


Mostly Cloudy

Currently: 68 °

Partly Sunny with Thunder Showers
Hi: 79° | Low: 56° | Humidity: 52%
Wind: CLM at 0 mph
More weather » | Tide Charts »
weatherIt's not always sunny in Southwest Florida. In our weather section, you can check out our radar which shows current conditions, severe weather and warns about possible hurricanes. You can also get the latest forecast in our interactive weather with Jim Syoen. Find out now »
Best reader-submitted photo
Photos

See local news, sports and features photos by NDN staff in our yearly review. View our photos »

View all of our videos »
View our photo galleries »
See user-submitted videos, photos »

NIE Cruise Contest

Newspapers in Education provides newspapers, lessons, Web site activities and links for local schools and homes. Donate newspapers to kids and earn a chance at a four-night cruise for two in the Caribbean! »

Swimsuit Edition 2008

It’s with great pleasure that we introduce Swimsuit 2008, our third annual swimwear edition. We take pride in the fact that all models involved are from right here in our community. This is where they live, work and play. Check it out! »