Documents
Not too long ago, few people in Collier County had ever heard of Jackson Laboratory, a nonprofit genetics research group headquartered in Bar Harbor, Maine.
Four staunch supporters began to change that after traveling to Maine and meeting Jackson scientists, and learning of their mission to help with the development of tailored therapies, based on individuals’ genetic composition, for disease prevention and treatment.
The number of local supporters has since swelled with the prospects that Jackson might build a research institute in eastern Collier, aided with local and state dollars, to stimulate the local economy.
“I’d like to say we struck a match and a bonfire started,” said Rainey Norins, a longtime Naples resident.
She and her husband, Dr. Leslie Norins, are half of the foursome. The other couple is Renee and Scott Relf.
In October 2007, Renee Relf founded and now chairs the Florida chapter of Jackson’s National Council, a volunteer group that strives to build awareness of Jackson, raise money for its research and host events to educate the public about human diseases.
Rainey Norins is vice chairwoman of the chapter.
For both women, their interest with Jackson began personally, with family members suffering debilitating illnesses and wishful thinking that meaningful treatment would arrive in time. That gave way to a broadened perspective of what the future may hold as genetic research moves toward targeted treatment _ personalized medicine_ and away from the historical realm of one-size-fits-all.
“They said, ‘We want to put Jackson on the map, we didn’t have much of a presence down here,” said Mike Hyde, vice president for advancement for Jackson.
In January 2008, a few months after starting the state chapter, Relf came up with the idea of a breakfast gathering the morning after a Naples Town Hall series event.
J. Craig Venter, a scientist not connected with Jackson, was the scheduled Town Hall speaker, where he intended to talk about the mapping of the human genome and his role in the scientific breakthrough in 2000.
For the breakfast event at Moorings Park retirement community the next day, Relf brought in Jackson’s president and chief executive officer, Dr. Rick Woychik. The idea was he would speak about what the human genome means to the individual.
But the afternoon of the Town Hall event, Venter’s plane was delayed due to weather. Woychik, already in Naples for his engagement the next day, was asked to fill in at Town Hall. He received a standing ovation after his presentation about personalized medicine.
* * * * *
Since starting the state chapter of Jackson’s volunteer network, Relf and Norins have organized a dozen or more local events with Jackson scientists speaking about different diseases and scientific developments.
“We have raised half a million (dollars) for research over the past three years,” Relf said. “Every person I come into contact with is very interested in research and how (they) can help get it closer to home.”
Some of Relf’s and Norins’ success stems from their leadership roles with the NCH Hospital Ball Committee, organizing the biggest annual fundraiser for the NCH Healthcare System.
From the start, Relf was up-front with Jackson officials about the Stadium Naples corruption scandal nearly a decade ago that ensnared several Collier commissioners.
She was Renee Tolson at the time; a partner of Maricopa Hardy Development Group, which pitched the $100-million golf spectator arena. In 2003, she pleaded no contest to a misdemeanor charge of failing to report currency to the state. She received a $5,000 fine.
“It does not come up (today),” Relf said of her involvement that time in her life. “I have done an enormous amount of volunteer work, philanthropy for this community. I have been a member of this community since 1990.”
Relf emphasizes she is strictly a volunteer for Jackson.
She and Norins describe themselves as being “infected” with the Jackson Laboratory “bug.”
“I am passionate about what the Jackson Laboratory is doing and what the National Council can do,” Relf said.
* * * * *
At one of the chapter events in March 2008 with Jackson scientists speaking, Tammie Nemecek, president and chief executive officer of the Economic Development Council, was in the audience.
Shortly after, Nemecek approached Jackson officials about considering a presence in Naples, Hyde said.
The EDC, through its Project Innovation with community leaders to revive the local economy, was looking to dovetail on how other Florida communities have pursued biomedical firms for economic diversification.
“It was sort of a chain of circumstances, of people meeting people,” Hyde said of how things have evolved to where they are today.
After more than a year of Jackson and the EDC exploring a collaboration behind the scenes, the EDC and community leaders this past spring pursued state funding for Jackson to build a research branch in Naples.
The Barron Collier Co. agreed to donate 50 acres off Oil Well Road as the site.
The state Legislature allocated first-year funding of $50 million in the state budget, which awaits Gov. Charlie Crist’s approval, with the pledge of another $80 million in subsequent years.
Collier County would be required to match the state funding. County leaders and the EDC say the decision needs to be made in the coming months whether to proceed and if so, how to generate the county match.
What’s envisioned locally is a larger biomedical research park, with other medical-related companies setting up shop in the vicinity and the potential creation of thousands of jobs in the next decade and beyond.
Relf and Norins stand ready to support the Naples project, but say their chapter fundraising, as determined by Jackson’s National Council, is limited to research funding and not capital campaigns.
“That needs to be led by Jackson,” Norins said. “Of course we are cheering for it and we think the idea is spectacular.”
Relf said regardless of what happens with the Naples project, her support of Jackson’s research and her role with the chapter won’t end.
“I think it would be sad if we lose them,” Relf said. “This is our rebirth. This is an opportunity to bring more jobs and create a surge in the construction industry. Our construction industry would be reinvigorated, our home sales would be reinvigorated. Scientists would come for conferences and fill up hotels and restaurants. To me, it is a no-brainer.’
At the same time, she understands concerns voiced by some about the county potentially spending $130 million to lure an out-of-state group to Naples in hopes large-scale job creation will happen down the road.
This past week, Hyde told an East Naples audience that Jackson sees having to bring $500 million to the Naples institute in the first 10 years before it could achieve financial stability. The risks are mutual, he said.
“We have to do something,” Relf said, referring to the stagnant local economy that can no longer survive on tourism, construction and banking. “If this isn’t it, what is it? We as a community have an awesome opportunity to band together as a medical destination.”
__ Connect with reporter Liz Freeman at www.naplesnews.com/staff/liz_freeman
Collier County arrests 05-22-2012
Punta Gorda Prostitution Arrests…
Southwest Florida home sales: May 22…














Scripps Interactive Newspapers Group
Comments » 27
GBR writes:
I was thinking of maybe a 10 year deal on property taxes and reduced or forgiven impact fees. They already are getting the land free.
Handing them $260 million on potentialy 200 jobs in 10 years?
The Cubs are looking better all the time.
;-)
loisbolin writes:
Why cant we have both -- still our community's long term economic stability needs a science based component. I dont think its 200 in 10 years - the clustering factor adds greatly to this number. As Project Innovation states: its a marathon - not a sprint. either way- we gotta take that first step.
kab269#227463 (Inactive) writes:
if it sounds to good, you know the rest. don't be fooled and used by jackson labs.
if you want to be here,
find your own money.
RainMan writes:
I for one, was orginally for the idea of bringing Jackson Labs here. Until, I read that they planned on funding it with an additional charge being added to my electric bill.
Personally speaking, the tax would only effect those living east of 75. Well, I really would find it hard to pay a higher electric bill. As it is now, my electric bill goes from a little over 250.00 a month in the seasonal months to over 500.00 a month through the summer months.
So, unless they come up with some other way to fund this, I am totally against it.
I have an idea, these governmental employees down here in southwest Florida, if they think this will really help us grow and our economy grow, should be the ones that fund it.
Show us how much you believe in this project, take a cut in pay, take a cut in health care, and take a cut in your government pensions to fund it. Then, if it actually stimulates the local economy, you can get your money back. Whom are you supposed to be working for anyways?
_________________________________________________
http://www.fairtax.org <--- Would instantly STIMULATE the American economy if inacted, something our poloticians don't seem to know how to do.
greathornedlizard writes:
(This comment was removed by the site staff.)
InformedOpinion writes:
Just a few questions:
Is it OK for the government to force private persons to subsidize somebody else's private business?
Do those forced to subsidize this private business get a percentage ownership in return for their money?
Why isn't the local "Tea Party" and others who usually complain the loudest shouting to high heaven about this governmental taking of personal property?
If this development is a good investment why doesn't the "free market" pay for it?
Is N.C.H. (mentioned in the article) or any other medical provider contributing with no ownership interest in return?
Is this already a "done deal"
Don't get me wrong -
this may be the greatest thing since sliced bread -
I don't have an opinion yet -
just questions.
napleschik writes:
If you do the research, you will find that the public will continue to pay for this as an ongoing venture the same way Maine pays for them. The County will also bear the burden to fill the new research park with tenants. There will be requests for funds as well. The 200 jobs that the lab will produce is not a good investment for 750 Mil over ten years. There is no guarantee they can make this a success. They won't commit that there will be more than 200 jobs. Who said if it smells bad I won't eat it?
Woodlands writes:
Jackson Labs is a wonderful operation but who pays and who benefits? Jackson gets their $260 Million. Barron Collier gets a jump start for their faltering Ave Marie project and Collier taxpayers get the bill in the form of taxes and surcharges. A State report published in January says the massive Florida investment in technology over the past years has yet to yield benefits, and may take DECADES!! Our economy is staggering, citizens losing homes at 350 to 500 per month and we are raising taxes for a possible return 20 years out? Hello! Collier Commissioners need to get a grip on reality! Local government needs to stop spending money we don't have. Now is no time for more public money and financing going to benefit developers.
rasputin writes:
Isn't science the complete opposite of the tbagging right wing? We all know praying is superior to medicine. How ironic.
This debacle has stench written all over it. If we don't vote the col. sanders-coyle & mushmouth colletta's out of office, it's gonna end up costing us alot more money in the long run. Fiscal conservatives. Yeah right. More like fiscal crooks.
beetlejuice writes:
Stop insanity already...seriously
napleschik writes:
Rasputin,
Coletta a fiscal conservative? He is a RINO.
Never met a tax or a cause he didn't like.
greathornedlizard writes:
Visualize whirled peas..
beetlejuice writes:
Visualize vanishing money
rasputin writes:
Napleschik, fiscally incompetent would be a better discription of mushmouth colletta. Come to think of it, you could leave out the word fiscally, and just go with plain old imcompetent to describe the retard.
naplestan writes:
Visualize a giant toilet with a vortex of undigested gold nibblets.
bobbo22 writes:
This is one giant scam. Evidence of this is one of the grifters promoting it.
swfldawg writes:
There will probably be a boom in medical technology over the next 20 years related to discoveries around the genome, but there is no guarantee Jackson Labs will be at the forefront or even a major player. The big boys aren't asking county and state governments for a quarter billion dollars to kickstart new labs. The big boys have raised and are continuing to raise billions through stock offerings(where you risk capital in exchange for a piece of the reward). I hope they are checking the books of this place...it sounds like the modern equivalent of snake oil. "Tell us what's wrong sister and we'll fix it with a customized, tailored, gee-neddic solution!!! Send in your checks!!"
napleschik writes:
Relf says it doesn't come up today? Sure does. She thinks we forgot? It all went away like magic? I still can't believe that any elected official will have anything to do with this. Oh, and the with the pledge of another $80 million in subsequent years? They have admitted there would be no guarantee of the state funds. It would depend on who is in office. A new Governor will undoubtedly wake up and see this for what it is.
cornandbeans writes:
Thanks NDN for exposing how this idea got started. Naples Stadium II.
I can't belierve anybody with a brain and a heart beat could be for the public funding of this project and Collier Enterprises. The Collier's have all ready suckered the taxpayers to build the road to no where aka, Oil Well Road.
Collier County - intergeneration suckers. We never learn! Just pay, pay, pay and more pay.
titanbite writes:
So,one of the party's that's been pushing this Jackson Lab's move from the start was involved in the Naples Stadium scandal and paid a $5,000 fine?
Oh,but she says she can be trusted now,OK,YEA RIGHT!
Great,this Bio-Tech business is really beginning to sound promising,NOT!
Here's a link to a regular occurrence in the Bio-Tech industry,with a bit of detail into the difficulties associated with developing pharmaceuticals and treatment techniques in the United States.
http://industry.bnet.com/pharma/10001...
The situation detailed in the link may not mirror the work done by Jackson Lab's exactly,but,they're subject to the same FDA approval processes as any other company trying to develop medical technology,a process of lengthy trails,some more than a decade long,with the potential to create many failures along the way.
Bio-tech research is extremely expensive,companies go belly up all the time simply because of the cost to gain FDA approval for their discoveries.
I honestly wish the reality was different,the statistics regarding genetic and pharmaceutical research show companies like Jackson Lab's failing to bring their discoveries to the market more often than not,can the County afford that investment risk.
Right now,I don't think so,coupled with the fact that a convicted fraud is involved,I don't see any advantage to investing in this extremely expensive and risky venture.
This project isn't coming to Naples for the good of the County,Jackson Lab's is coming because it's good for them and those involved in the land surrounding the site.
I'm sure there will be a great deal of money to be made from any building associated with the Lab,homes for 200 workers comes to mind,whoever has control over that stands to profit handsomely.
To say "our construction industry will be reinvigorated",is ridicules,one business and 200 homes,C'MON!
Who will benefit the most financially with this project?
It won't be the County or anyone forced to pay for this project through whatever means they decide to take the money from us.
We,the Taxpayer's will end up holding the bag of bio-medical waste,you can count on that.
Bramble writes:
Where does this $260 million come from? Not thin air! It comes from state legislators raiding trust funds and social programs (putting thousands of jobs and lives at risk). Where will the county's share come from--taxes on what, fees on what? How much will they be taking from our families for this project?
To me, it looks like the majority of public funding will benefit two of the already most wealthy and healty local organizations: the Colliers and the largest construction conractor around these parts whose new owners live in New York. The third beneficiary will be already wealthy Jackson Laboratory.
Though the project might produce a surge in construction activity, many of the workers and materials(and beneficiaries)of this will undoubtedly come from Lee and other surrounding counties. That's fine except it's Collier Taxpayers who are expected to pay for half of this project. And will there be any help money left for other projects after so much is spent on this one business and its 200 jobs in 5 years??
We have so many local businesses hurting now. Half of the amount we would be giving to an out of state wealthy company (Jackson)could really be better spent as a lifesaver for local commerce to renovate, expand, advertise and hire locally right now.
We can't wait two or three decades to see if the big plans for Jackson work out. Our community needs help now.
Dbess writes:
If there is no market for this company here, it should not be here. That is common business sense. Using taxpayer dollars to subsidize this move is unethical and unsustainable.
napleschik writes:
Do we want to submit Collier County to the endless national media scrutiny of PETA protests, patent infringement lawsuits - they have one- and heaven forbid one of the infected mice gets loose. Bad decision making by bureaucrats. Did anyone see our commissioner at the GGEACA meeting with the Jackson Labs people? We need to change the laws in Collier regarding lobbying. This is stadium Naples II. Now we know why they don't want our Clerk to audit them. And they say they don't want to be known like the last commissioners. Right.
angrytxpyr writes:
(This comment was removed by the site staff.)
angrytxpyr writes:
(This comment was removed by the site staff.)
anotherPOV writes:
The liberal elite on the left and the conservative troglodytes on the right finally agreeing on something. Puts a warm fuzzy feeling in your heart, don't it.
beetlejuice writes:
WELL SAID!
Share your thoughts
Comments are the sole responsibility of the person posting them. You agree not to post comments that are off topic, defamatory, obscene, abusive, threatening or an invasion of privacy. Violators may be banned. Click here for our full user agreement.